Pan Protectors vs Paper Towels: Which Keeps Pans Safe?
By Made In Cookware - UK | Published: 2026-10-28
Category: Comparisons
Wondering whether to use pan protectors or paper towels for storing your pans? We compare both options to help you keep your cookware scratch-free.
Quick answer
For most kitchens, dedicated pan protectors are the safer choice for stacking pans without scratching, especially for nonstick and stainless steel cookware. Paper towels can work in a pinch, but they tear, shift, and don't provide consistent cushioning.
Why paper towels fall short
Paper towels are cheap and always on hand, but they aren't designed for cookware storage. When you stack pans, the weight of the top pan compresses the paper, and any grit or food residue on the pan surface can still cause micro-scratches. Paper towels also tear easily, especially if a pan edge catches them, leaving gaps in protection.
For nonstick pans, scratches are more than cosmetic—they can damage the coating over time. Paper towels offer minimal padding and can shift when you slide a pan in or out of a cabinet, which means the protection is inconsistent.
What pan protectors do differently
Pan protectors are purpose-built for this job. The Made In Pan Protectors are designed to fit between each size of Made In Frying Pans, creating a consistent barrier that prevents metal-on-metal contact. They're made from FDA-approved silicone, so they're food-safe and won't absorb odors or moisture.
Because they're silicone, they stay in place better than paper and provide a cushion that absorbs impact. They're also dishwasher safe, which makes cleanup easy if they pick up any grease or residue.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Cost and convenience: Paper towels are cheaper upfront and require no special purchase. Pan protectors are a one-time investment that lasts for years. If you only stack pans occasionally, paper towels may be enough; for regular use, protectors pay off.
- Protection level: Paper towels provide thin, compressible padding that can tear or shift. Silicone pan protectors offer consistent, durable cushioning that prevents scratches even with heavy pans. Choose protectors if you value long-term cookware appearance and performance.
- Ease of use: Paper towels are disposable and easy to replace, but you need to fold them to fit. Pan protectors are sized to fit Made In frying pans and simply drop in place. Protectors save time and reduce waste compared to using paper towels.
Product facts
- Pan Protectors: Designed to fit between each size of Made In Frying Pans for easy, scratch-free stacking. This means you get consistent coverage without having to fold or adjust the protector each time you stack.
Pan Protectors - Pan Protectors: Made from FDA-approved silicone and dishwasher safe. Silicone is durable, non-slip, and easy to clean, so the protectors stay hygienic and effective over time.
Which should you choose?
Best for
- Home cooks who stack pans regularly and want reliable scratch prevention
- Owners of nonstick or stainless steel pans who want to extend cookware life
Not for
- Occasional stackers who don't mind replacing paper towels frequently
- Those who prefer disposable, zero-maintenance options
